Math and Stats

Classroom tools

Build a Counterexample

Can two datasets share a mean and a median but have different spreads?

Start with the matching sets. Change two values in B while keeping its total fixed, then check whether your pair disproves the claim.

Enter five integers from −1,000 to 1,000 in each set. Separate them with spaces or commas. Repeated values are allowed.

Get a hint

Check the argument

    Values for the checked pair
    MeasureSet ASet B
    Teacher notes and worked example

    A universal claim of the form “whenever P holds, Q holds” is false if a single example satisfies P and makes Q false. An example that satisfies both leaves the universal claim undecided.

    Each mean is the sum divided by five. The median is the third ordered observation. Sample variance is the sum of the squared distances from the mean divided by four; sample SD is its positive square root, or zero for a constant dataset. The table includes the exact variance so students can distinguish close spreads.